So you call your doctor and ask, "What's all this I've been hearing about green tea and radishes and turmeric and...?" And you expect her to have an answer, or have scientific reasons for or against drinking a gallon of green tea a day. Or at least to have a clue. Right?
Interestingly, med school curriculla usually do not include courses that teach, or even expose, their students the various properties that food--which we put into our bodies 3+ times a day--has on our health, on our bodies, on our ability to prevent or battle disease. Sure, we know that obesity is bad, that trans fats are bad, that eating too much fatty and processed food is bad. We know all about Type 2 Diabetes and Heart Disease and Hypertension. But what about the flip side? What about using food to our benefit, using food to detoxify, to help prevent disease, to help battle disease? What is the real deal with Omega-3's--are they in all fish? What exactly is the difference between "red meat" and "white meat", if both come from the muscle of animals? What foods are really good at decreasing LDL and VLDL, the "bad" cholesterols?
Unfortunately, allopathic medical schools are notoriously focused on the treatment of symptoms, on curing diseased systems once they've gone awry. They stress pathology and the drugs to reverse the pathology. They push prevention in the form of "eat right, exercise, don't smoke." And don't get me wrong, all of this is very important. But what they don't do is teach their students about holistic patient care, of prevention via lifestyle changes and maintenance of healthy habits. And if allopathic medical schools don't do this, that means most MD's out there don't know this, and that probably means your doctor has very little clue what the science is behind what you heard about green tea and radishes and turmeric (and...). Most of this information--and the beliefs and research about it--falls under the category of Complimentary and Alternative Medicine, or CAM, like signs of "pre-diabetes" and the healing power of acupuncture--now medically recognized as legitimate phenomena--once were. Like progress in politics, progress in medically acceptable beliefs is slow to catch on. And, like in politics, there needs to be a public force to accelerate change. So I'm hoping to do my very small part by blogging about the things that I learn in my Nutrition & Medicine course. It's only 6 weeks long, of which I've already completed 2. But there has been a lot learned, and so there should be a lot to write. I'll add a little Intro to N&M below, but stay tuned. And if you have questions you want me to relay to my course instructors, please let me know!
OK, so here's my sad attempt at:
Introduction to Nutrition & Medicine
- Ever wonder if that Centrum is actually doing you good? At a recent NIH conference solely devoted to the topic of daily multivitamins, the consensus was: They're probably not helping you. In fact, they might actually be harming you.
If you're supplementing a weak diet with a daily multivitamin, consider taking individual supplements (Vitamin D if you're not getting enough sunlight, Calcium for almost everyone, with an emphasis on woman over 20) to patch the holes in your lifestyle/diet, instead. But better yet: start eating more foods with those nutrients that you're missing. This brings me to an important point: NOTHING can replace good, fresh, whole foods. When you eat fresh whole foods, the nutrients in them have maximal bioavailability, because they are in the form that your body is able to recognize and absorb. A multivitamin is clearly not a natural or whole substance, and some of the "vitamins" in them are in a different chemical form than the true vitamin has in whole food. The chart at the bottom this site has a good chart of dietary sources of vitamins & minerals. - Do you know if you're getting enough Vitamin D? Do you know how much sodium you eat each day? If you're interested in getting a breakdown of the strengths & weaknesses of your daily nutritional intake, you can input your food intake an analysis at this site.
You'll have to set up a profile, and it's fairly laborious and annoying to do the actual input, but it's a good resource to "get an idea" of just how good you're being. I personally had no clue what my actual cholesterol intake was, and was surprised to see how low some of my vitamin levels were... and I'm kind of a health food nut! So I recommend it for anyone who has a little time to spare to sate some curiosity. Alternatively, there are a lot of pay-for-service sites that are much better, if you're less economically challenged and really want to get into it.
3 comments:
So any assessment on a vegetarian diet? Any secrets on losing weight other than to use more calories than you consume?
Thanks for the info and direction to the sites -- I played with the energy burner -- did you know that you will burn more energy with exercise if you weigh more -- hmmm perhaps that could be my approach to higher calorie burning exercise?
Also I was surprised by the list of foods that were offered for low fat diets -- including things like coke and frosting -- shouldn't there be a "don't be stupid" filter rather than a pride of completeness? Please don't tell me there are people who should be eating things like that -- at that point life would be too unfair!
Ok, I need to go steam some broccoli and saute spinach in 3 drops of olive oil!
Very interesting. Keep the info coming!
My question would be when you do hear something like green tea is the best thing ever is there somewhere they recommend looking to for reliable (and non-fad following) information? And I guess there might be two answers - one for the med students and one for the general public. The other piece would be is there somewhere that keeps a list of the latest updates so you don't have to wait for someone to say they heard something about green tea to go look it up?
I'm not sure if this is exactly a question, but one of the things I struggle with when looking at this stuff is how different concerns compare with each other. In engineering if I am building a circuit and part of it is using 100 watts and I'm working on another part that uses about 1 watt I'll try to keep from using more power than necessary, but I'm not going to work real hard at it. For health stuff - it would be nice to get more of a sense if getting my vitamin balance right is the biggest thing I could do or if talking a 5 minute walk every day would do vastly more good or if I only get a benefit if I get both right. Obviously the case you are talking about is a bit different since there I could stop doing something and probably be better off. I guess after all that I'm curious how to gauge the relative importance of various health concerns.
that little bit about drinking a gallon of green tea a day...was that an intentional ribbing directed toward me? Or were you unaware that I'm almost never seen without my half-gallon jug of wawa green tea cradled to my chest?
What are you doing 7/21?! Any definite plans?
peasout
Angie
Post a Comment